$400$500$600$700$800$900$1,000$1,100$1,200$1,300$1,400$1,500$1,600$1,700$1,800$1,900$2,000$2,200$2,400$2,500$2,600$2,800$3,000$3,200$3,400$3,500$3,600$3,800$4,000$4,200$4,400$4,500$4,600$4,800$5,000$7,500$10,000$15,000 1 bedroom2 bedrooms3 bedrooms4 bedrooms5+ bedrooms
to
Single Family
![32 Agnew Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/4/f/1/a/picture-uh=866432da8f6bdf0c067dc48d9ec4b42-ps=4f1ab3df69cfb31ad27424c91a9ceee.jpg)
![32 Agnew Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/d/e/1/a/picture-uh=27cc5aacd9e6d99f4678c724ada4b7-ps=de1ac127318ee1adb1b96acaec0e94d.jpg)
![32 Agnew Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/c/5/e/5/picture-uh=127f90dd829e7c7ce43a18167e4c-ps=c5e58b59958492fefe1c5b3ebdfd3d7a.jpg)
![32 Agnew Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/d/0/4/4/picture-uh=5e73141395066fb142e55e66c229077-ps=d044ad9e6712816eb742bdd3be91d4a.jpg)
More property photos
$25,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1200 sqft
Single Family
![21 Butternut Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/2/7/2/8/picture-uh=1079fb62994686f58f0de7e7a8de591-ps=27282b1c18556c1225573e25cf4ae.jpg)
![21 Butternut Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/2/7/2/8/picture-uh=1079fb62994686f58f0de7e7a8de591-ps=27282b1c18556c1225573e25cf4ae.jpg)
More property photos
$13,500
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1.5 baths
- Floor size: 2000 sqft
Single-Family Home
![9 Caswell Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.94/4/0/7/1/picture-uh=4b6f1ad91912339a76e4c759c82d381-ps=40718fd0c631916b2be4e825a8f21cbf.jpg)
$10,000
Recently rented
Single-Family Home
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 650 sqft
Single Family
![23 Deforest Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.87/e/1/2/f/picture-uh=f0fab5e6f8eae57d51903269afb5f9e-ps=e12fc5c06377d6c7217542954eba1f8.jpg)
![23 Deforest Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.87/a/d/7/2/picture-uh=cac9349af4cade387e0ee4b7e9c3887-ps=ad72aa7896bd6772436186bce0eb9ca2.jpg)
![23 Deforest Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.95/e/1/2/f/picture-uh=f0fab5e6f8eae57d51903269afb5f9e-ps=e12fc5c06377d6c7217542954eba1f8.jpg)
![23 Deforest Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.95/a/d/7/2/picture-uh=cac9349af4cade387e0ee4b7e9c3887-ps=ad72aa7896bd6772436186bce0eb9ca2.jpg)
More property photos
$25,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1000 sqft
Single Family
![3 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/5/4/4/1/picture-uh=ebabbed221751cb35faf22b162eb2ef0-ps=544111791ce9c50692f758fd259c2a4.jpg)
![3 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/e/5/7/7/picture-uh=dfa59ae32192c056b1fe302010f5ca4b-ps=e577d93fd89fa131b83cee094b3898a.jpg)
![3 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/5/4/4/1/picture-uh=ebabbed221751cb35faf22b162eb2ef0-ps=544111791ce9c50692f758fd259c2a4.jpg)
![3 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/e/5/7/7/picture-uh=dfa59ae32192c056b1fe302010f5ca4b-ps=e577d93fd89fa131b83cee094b3898a.jpg)
More property photos
$70,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1200 sqft
Single Family
![27 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/2/d/a/7/picture-uh=5e8cec2cff16c8f51d4d21552c84dd3-ps=2da7783a25f6b9c84f1ddd9138505f18.jpg)
![27 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/a/0/8/b/picture-uh=8e94c23f6304714653922d610224292-ps=a08bdaf677cf989e21983219b169dbc.jpg)
![27 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/2/d/a/7/picture-uh=5e8cec2cff16c8f51d4d21552c84dd3-ps=2da7783a25f6b9c84f1ddd9138505f18.jpg)
![27 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/a/0/8/b/picture-uh=8e94c23f6304714653922d610224292-ps=a08bdaf677cf989e21983219b169dbc.jpg)
More property photos
$24,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 600 sqft
Single Family
![30 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/f/b/c/c/picture-uh=13a232f83b5326a6a7fd4c579b422785-ps=fbccf4dc5a6649703474fe55d7292.jpg)
![30 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.87/e/1/b/3/picture-uh=a0ac2cb14bc5608e7e3d4347450bd2-ps=e1b31cf5cf3b718e91a72641e489bd.jpg)
![30 Ditch Plains Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/f/b/c/c/picture-uh=13a232f83b5326a6a7fd4c579b422785-ps=fbccf4dc5a6649703474fe55d7292.jpg)
More property photos
$18,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1000 sqft
Single Family
![27 Duryea Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/7/7/a/1/picture-uh=d9b5c35271ee9842e1fab1545984a1d-ps=77a1233496fd79dd861a52858c9d4fee.jpg)
![27 Duryea Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/6/6/5/f/picture-uh=372f457b3613ce2c393e14b3f03c8394-ps=665fbec626462afe05932c05e83ccda.jpg)
![27 Duryea Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/7/7/a/1/picture-uh=d9b5c35271ee9842e1fab1545984a1d-ps=77a1233496fd79dd861a52858c9d4fee.jpg)
![27 Duryea Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.84/6/6/5/f/picture-uh=372f457b3613ce2c393e14b3f03c8394-ps=665fbec626462afe05932c05e83ccda.jpg)
More property photos
$10,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1000 sqft
![71 Edgemere, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.89/d/2/f/b/picture-uh=756a132314b9b103aebaea2a0f61adc-ps=d2fb20bbe423d6ff29c84e2636790e9.jpg)
![71 Edgemere, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.89/c/5/2/9/picture-uh=d1804edb8c6b33b4b33430faa8562-ps=c52934b5eb1d51c095e39a509bb457d0.jpg)
![71 Edgemere, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.95/d/2/f/b/picture-uh=756a132314b9b103aebaea2a0f61adc-ps=d2fb20bbe423d6ff29c84e2636790e9.jpg)
More property photos
$75,000
Recently rented
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 900 sqft
![85 S Edison St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.76/a/b/f/4/picture-uh=03f1ef456b7c65898c36c10faf8e38-ps=abf41454d671deeb2fa4844d55d476f.jpg)
![85 S Edison St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/2/5/6/7/picture-uh=03f1ef456b7c65898c36c10faf8e38-ps=2567a07c6aa5cc6d66e0ac3352937a3e.jpg)
![85 S Edison St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/2/5/6/7/picture-uh=03f1ef456b7c65898c36c10faf8e38-ps=2567a07c6aa5cc6d66e0ac3352937a3e.jpg)
![85 S Edison St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/c/4/6/c/picture-uh=e8613dedd63f9d491f3a4c7f3b1127b-ps=c46caa843525aff43539945f8ce8ef4.jpg)
More property photos
$3,500
Recently rented
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 600 sqft
Single Family
![26 S Elroy Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/e/3/e/6/picture-uh=098fa62d6d23b0219148144b8f4313-ps=e3e6acf46cd05543ea9859f3bed8bf4.jpg)
![26 S Elroy Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/5/7/3/6/picture-uh=c8dd1c3b22f73bcaf15b443a02515-ps=5736b3fae801464b8c162aa53e057.jpg)
![26 S Elroy Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/e/3/e/6/picture-uh=098fa62d6d23b0219148144b8f4313-ps=e3e6acf46cd05543ea9859f3bed8bf4.jpg)
![26 S Elroy Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/5/7/3/6/picture-uh=c8dd1c3b22f73bcaf15b443a02515-ps=5736b3fae801464b8c162aa53e057.jpg)
More property photos
$25,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1400 sqft
Single Family
![110 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.82/5/b/3/9/picture-uh=19eff64d7cf81ac6dd9bd4b159a73ef-ps=5b39deb53b016e3ee0a5717ce7a84f.jpg)
![110 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.82/4/9/3/4/picture-uh=335ffe93bf882430e16e62fefd77bfc5-ps=493426b009f146b762aeec79cea9848.jpg)
![110 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.88/e/0/f/9/picture-uh=8998cfd6c628a450812ed5a5b675a9b-ps=e0f99bffc611b8f0591a13ef4b1d158.jpg)
![110 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.88/5/b/3/9/picture-uh=19eff64d7cf81ac6dd9bd4b159a73ef-ps=5b39deb53b016e3ee0a5717ce7a84f.jpg)
More property photos
$4,500
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 2 baths
- Floor size: 1300 sqft
Single Family
![177 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.88/1/8/d/2/picture-uh=8d3517c7932d86bc42561bbdcbe216-ps=18d2192bf9dbc98cffef400ae26b752.jpg)
![177 S Fairview Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.94/a/b/4/7/picture-uh=d2a49bf7e5f7e1e75c9cbb3c3f52959-ps=ab47713578b47e31fd55ebd107ba26a.jpg)
More property photos
$18,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1000 sqft
![52 Fairway Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/4/2/5/4/picture-uh=1d2f5b64b7bded1b9c1ba76883371ee-ps=4254899b8a38cd3b78afc5ef687c7071.jpg)
![52 Fairway Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/3/7/4/e/picture-uh=71b7b05a548f40b2387974488dbdca-ps=374e8ee36c224cab0ab9c2432a0eba7.jpg)
![52 Fairway Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/4/2/5/4/picture-uh=1d2f5b64b7bded1b9c1ba76883371ee-ps=4254899b8a38cd3b78afc5ef687c7071.jpg)
![52 Fairway Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.83/3/7/4/e/picture-uh=71b7b05a548f40b2387974488dbdca-ps=374e8ee36c224cab0ab9c2432a0eba7.jpg)
More property photos
$10,000
Recently rented
- 2 beds
- 2.5 baths
- Floor size: 1875 sqft
Single Family
![61 Greenwich St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.81/5/b/3/4/picture-uh=7d23ba55caf228c21a315383b3c87a4-ps=5b342098c08917adbc2c938d3f1cbb2.jpg)
![61 Greenwich St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.81/2/9/2/0/picture-uh=1895cdeb885e65ba9d194b5fe6174f50-ps=292049fcb3be7868d39ca5c6a7cc7.jpg)
![61 Greenwich St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.81/2/9/2/0/picture-uh=1895cdeb885e65ba9d194b5fe6174f50-ps=292049fcb3be7868d39ca5c6a7cc7.jpg)
![61 Greenwich St, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.81/5/b/3/4/picture-uh=7d23ba55caf228c21a315383b3c87a4-ps=5b342098c08917adbc2c938d3f1cbb2.jpg)
More property photos
$12,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1.5 baths
- Floor size: 1200 sqft
Single Family
![6 Hoyt Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.76/4/8/8/f/picture-uh=3c42ceec89e2d877d977b4ea4f587bf9-ps=488f385161bbc5135153456c55f949.jpg)
![6 Hoyt Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.86/1/2/8/9/picture-uh=f513e119d25825befc47e760f2ffcb-ps=128953eaecc52ce4b0d6b5ec5b5ead58.jpg)
![6 Hoyt Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.86/4/8/8/f/picture-uh=8b7d53ae62975efb4deffc417f82afc-ps=488f385161bbc5135153456c55f949.jpg)
![6 Hoyt Pl, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.87/5/4/8/2/picture-uh=25f26378e6fe337a7c726a0aef57a4e-ps=5482f5c30bb78e6964b75911560fad0.jpg)
More property photos
$12,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 800 sqft
Unspecified
![421 E Lake Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/d/3/a/3/picture-uh=b8558c1fa5cd9a4b7dbdadfcc09ce612-ps=d3a3e18b9bafbbeb3ff9969aa746b48.jpg)
![421 E Lake Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/a/a/f/4/picture-uh=f0c1317a44658553488fdfab4479a5-ps=aaf48d0c1404ef2cdc5fa419e22b055.jpg)
![421 E Lake Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/a/a/f/4/picture-uh=f0c1317a44658553488fdfab4479a5-ps=aaf48d0c1404ef2cdc5fa419e22b055.jpg)
![421 E Lake Dr, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.85/5/f/e/8/picture-uh=4ce34231e1724a9ee51a5c2475f4eeba-ps=5fe81c9786c83483f887873b1a1a02b.jpg)
More property photos
$14,000
Recently rented
Unspecified
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1000 sqft
![421 Old Montauk Hwy, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/7/b/d/b/picture-uh=8cbf12afa09ad846a59c77af4f52c2a8-ps=7bdb4dcc4527c3ca27cc2f77e9c9406c.jpg)
![421 Old Montauk Hwy, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.80/7/b/d/b/picture-uh=8cbf12afa09ad846a59c77af4f52c2a8-ps=7bdb4dcc4527c3ca27cc2f77e9c9406c.jpg)
More property photos
$17,000
Recently rented
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1100 sqft
Single Family
![28 Rehan Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](https://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.71/4/e/7/5/picture-uh=b8111a2f33bc8986d2b21f7c0281b7d-ps=4e752b9ba5a2dea8b4fbcee3fa3e510.jpg)
![28 Rehan Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.71/3/3/1/5/picture-uh=f780b5ce0d5c7eca6aa20a32147c3bd-ps=3315c6e0b2279a4e446cfe0afd9474.jpg)
![28 Rehan Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.71/4/e/7/5/picture-uh=b8111a2f33bc8986d2b21f7c0281b7d-ps=4e752b9ba5a2dea8b4fbcee3fa3e510.jpg)
![28 Rehan Ave, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.90/c/6/3/8/picture-uh=5bf07b48458f25e935a22f5864813b-ps=c6381267f473a3183238ca0e1fb813a.jpg)
More property photos
$3,000
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 1400 sqft
Single Family
![63 Second House Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.88/4/d/c/f/picture-uh=9494ac8d5a2d3f895adafc136e302c-ps=4dcf6212432d63a1659f4b659e5154.jpg)
![63 Second House Rd, Hither Plains, NY 11954](http://thumbs.trulia-cdn.com/pictures/thumbs_3/ps.88/a/9/4/b/picture-uh=5eaca62b912a4216840cce927472953-ps=a94bb1a3ef486153883b38ff3ba3e.jpg)
More property photos
$13,500
Recently rented
Single Family
- 2 beds
- 1 bath
- Floor size: 896 sqft